Skip to content

Penny’s Surprise

Country/region

  • Australia AUD $
  • Bahamas BSD $
  • Canada CAD $
  • Jamaica JMD $
  • New Zealand NZD $
  • South Africa USD $
  • United Kingdom GBP £
  • United States USD $
Log in Cart

Item added to your cart

View cart
  • Gift Card Holder - Christmas Gift Box Gift Card Holder - Christmas Gift Box

    Gift Card Holder - Christmas Gift Box

    Gift Card Holder - Christmas Gift Box

    Regular price $6.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $6.00 USD
  • Gift Card Holder - JOLLY Christmas Gift Card Holder - JOLLY Christmas

    Gift Card Holder - JOLLY Christmas

    Gift Card Holder - JOLLY Christmas

    Regular price $6.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $6.00 USD
  • Gift Tag - Basketball Lovers

    Gift Tag - Basketball Lovers

    Gift Tag - Basketball Lovers

    Regular price $8.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $8.00 USD
  • Gift Tag - Bear Hug

    Gift Tag - Bear Hug

    Gift Tag - Bear Hug

    Regular price $10.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $10.00 USD
  • Gift Tag - Bird in Flight

    Gift Tag - Bird in Flight

    Gift Tag - Bird in Flight

    Regular price $8.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $8.00 USD
  • Gift Tag - Bowling Ball Strike

    Gift Tag - Bowling Ball Strike

    Gift Tag - Bowling Ball Strike

    Regular price $8.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $8.00 USD
  • Gift Tag - Classic Sedan

    Gift Tag - Classic Sedan

    Gift Tag - Classic Sedan

    Regular price $8.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $8.00 USD
  • Gift Tag - Classic Square

    Gift Tag - Classic Square

    Gift Tag - Classic Square

    Regular price $5.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $5.00 USD
  • Gift Tag - Colorful Fall Leaf Gift Tag - Colorful Fall Leaf

    Gift Tag - Colorful Fall Leaf

    Gift Tag - Colorful Fall Leaf

    Regular price $8.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $8.00 USD
  • Gift Tag - Gold Stars

    Gift Tag - Gold Stars

    Gift Tag - Gold Stars

    Regular price $10.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $10.00 USD
  • Gift Tag - Harvest Produce

    Gift Tag - Harvest Produce

    Gift Tag - Harvest Produce

    Regular price $10.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $10.00 USD
  • Gift Tag - Heart Shape

    Gift Tag - Heart Shape

    Gift Tag - Heart Shape

    Regular price $8.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $8.00 USD
  • Gift Tag - Jurassic Classic Dinosaur

    Gift Tag - Jurassic Classic Dinosaur

    Gift Tag - Jurassic Classic Dinosaur

    Regular price $8.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $8.00 USD
  • Gift Tag - Oh, Hockey Sticks

    Gift Tag - Oh, Hockey Sticks

    Gift Tag - Oh, Hockey Sticks

    Regular price $8.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $8.00 USD
  • Gift Tag - Pink and Red Leaf Tags

    Gift Tag - Pink and Red Leaf Tags

    Gift Tag - Pink and Red Leaf Tags

    Regular price $8.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $8.00 USD
  • Gift Tag - Pretty Lady's Shoe

    Gift Tag - Pretty Lady's Shoe

    Gift Tag - Pretty Lady's Shoe

    Regular price $8.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $8.00 USD
  • Gift Tag - Pro Bowling Athlete

    Gift Tag - Pro Bowling Athlete

    Gift Tag - Pro Bowling Athlete

    Regular price $8.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $8.00 USD
  • Gift Tag - Retro High-Top Tennis Shoe

    Gift Tag - Retro High-Top Tennis Shoe

    Gift Tag - Retro High-Top Tennis Shoe

    Regular price $8.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $8.00 USD
  • Gift Tag - Round Shape

    Gift Tag - Round Shape

    Gift Tag - Round Shape

    Regular price $5.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $5.00 USD
  • Gift Tag - Shiny Apple

    Gift Tag - Shiny Apple

    Gift Tag - Shiny Apple

    Regular price $10.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $10.00 USD
  • Gift Tag - Special Delivery Truck

    Gift Tag - Special Delivery Truck

    Gift Tag - Special Delivery Truck

    Regular price $8.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $8.00 USD
  • Gift Tag - T-Shirt

    Gift Tag - T-Shirt

    Gift Tag - T-Shirt

    Regular price $8.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $8.00 USD
  • Gift Tag - Tennis Shoe

    Gift Tag - Tennis Shoe

    Gift Tag - Tennis Shoe

    Regular price $8.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $8.00 USD
  • Gift Tag - Thanks with Autumn Leaves Gift Tag - Thanks with Autumn Leaves

    Gift Tag - Thanks with Autumn Leaves

    Gift Tag - Thanks with Autumn Leaves

    Regular price $8.00 USD
    Regular price Sale price $8.00 USD
View all

Let's Celebrate!

Penny's Surprise specializes in creating unique, high-quality gift packaging essentials designed to make your gifts and presents memorable. We provide you with the right wrapping accessories, and we make it simple to add a personalized, thoughtful touch.

Why Choose Penny's Surprise?

Thoughtful Gift Tags: Explore our collection of handmade gift tags (like our popular rustic kraft paper tags with cutouts) perfect for every holiday, birthday, and thank-you occasion. They are the low-cost essential that adds big impact to your gifts.

Unique Gift Card Holders: Elevate cash or gift cards from boring to beautiful with our specialty holders. Find unique designs that fit your style, ensuring your gift feels just as personal as a wrapped present.

Penny's Surprise is dedicated to providing you with the best value in gift wrapping supplies. We're the perfect partner for thoughtful gift givers, party planners, and small business owners alike. Shop our collection today and make every gift shine!

Country/region

  • Australia AUD $
  • Bahamas BSD $
  • Canada CAD $
  • Jamaica JMD $
  • New Zealand NZD $
  • South Africa USD $
  • United Kingdom GBP £
  • United States USD $
Payment methods
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa
© 2025, Penny’s Surprise Powered by Shopify
  • Privacy policy
  • Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
  • Opens in a new window.